The Subchapter V Trustee: What Business Owners Need to Know
By
Ira Reid, Esq., Partner, J. Singer Law Group, PLLC


A Subchapter V trustee is appointed in every Subchapter V bankruptcy case, but that does not mean someone takes over your company. Unlike a Chapter 7 trustee, the Subchapter V trustee primarily helps the business and its creditors work toward a reorganization plan. In most cases, the owner keeps running the company. For business owners worried that filing means handing over the keys, this distinction matters.
Subchapter V is part of Chapter 11 and makes reorganization more manageable for qualifying small businesses. Congress created it through the Small Business Reorganization Act of 2019, Pub. L. 116-54, which took effect on February 19, 2020. The business generally stays in possession of its assets and continues operating while the trustee works with the parties on a plan. The trustee does not run the business.
What Is a Subchapter V Trustee?
A Subchapter V trustee is an independent fiduciary appointed by the U.S. Trustee to assist with the reorganization. Every Subchapter V case has one. The appointment is a routine part of the process, not an accusation that the owner mismanaged the business or did anything wrong. In an ordinary case, the trustee works to put a plan in place while management continues to run operations.
Created by the Small Business Reorganization Act of 2019
Congress enacted the Small Business Reorganization Act on August 23, 2019, and it became effective on February 19, 2020. The goal was to give eligible small businesses a less expensive, less cumbersome way to reorganize under Chapter 11. Subchapter V uses a trustee to help the parties reach an agreement, generally requires a plan within 90 days of filing, and usually proceeds without a creditors' committee. Our discussion of understanding Subchapter 5 bankruptcy in New York explains how these differences affect the process.
The Debtor in Possession Retains Control
In most Subchapter V cases, the business owner remains in control. You continue making day-to-day decisions, managing employees, and paying regular business expenses within the bankruptcy case's rules. You also work with your attorney to put together a reorganization plan. The trustee does not step in to run the business or take over its finances. Unless the court finds a legal reason to remove the debtor from possession, management stays in place.
What Are the Statutory Duties of the Subchapter V Trustee Under 11 U.S.C. § 1183(b)?
The trustee has a specific job in a Subchapter V case. They attend the meeting of creditors, help the business and its creditors work toward a reorganization plan everyone can agree on, and report on those efforts. If the court confirms a plan without creditor consent, the trustee generally must make payments under the plan. That does not mean the trustee starts running the company. The business owner normally stays in charge of daily operations.
Facilitating a Consensual Reorganization Plan
A central part of the trustee's work is getting the business and its creditors to a deal they can live with. The debtor generally has 90 days from filing to submit a plan, although the court can extend that deadline when the statutory requirements are met. Creditors do not have to agree for the court to confirm a plan. The court can confirm a plan over objections, but contested confirmation usually takes more work and costs more. A trustee who understands the business's finances and the creditors' concerns can help narrow those disputes early.
Monitoring, Reporting, and Compensation
The trustee stays involved throughout the Subchapter V case, reviews financial records, reports on negotiations with creditors, and tracks the reorganization's progress. If the court approves a plan without creditor consent, the trustee generally makes payments to creditors unless the court orders a different arrangement. The trustee also gets paid for that work, subject to court approval. Business owners should include that cost when determining whether the reorganization plan is financially realistic.
How Does the Subchapter V Trustee Differ from Other Trustee Roles?
The word "trustee" means different things in different bankruptcy cases. A Chapter 7 trustee generally gathers and sells nonexempt assets for creditors. A trustee appointed in an ordinary Chapter 11 case can replace management when the court finds cause. A Subchapter V trustee is appointed in every case but usually works with a business that remains in possession and continues operating.
Subchapter V Trustee vs. Chapter 7 Trustee
In a Chapter 7 business bankruptcy, the trustee takes control of the bankruptcy estate’s assets, sells property when necessary, and uses the proceeds to pay creditors according to bankruptcy rules. Most businesses filing Chapter 7 are preparing to close, although some operations can continue with court authorization. Subchapter V works differently. The business generally stays open, the owner continues running it, and the trustee helps the business and its creditors work toward a reorganization plan. Both are titled trustee, but they serve very different purposes.
Subchapter V Trustee vs. Traditional Chapter 11 Trustee
An ordinary Chapter 11 case usually starts with the debtor running its own business. The court appoints a trustee only when it finds a legal basis, such as fraud, dishonesty, incompetence, or gross mismanagement. Subchapter V works differently because the court appoints a trustee from the start without finding any wrongdoing. Subchapter V's advantages over Chapter 11 include simpler procedures and the trustee's role in helping reach an agreement. Traditional Chapter 11 bankruptcy for small businesses can involve a creditors' committee and more administrative expense, depending on the case.
What Does the Subchapter V Trustee Do with Merchant Cash Advance Obligations?
Merchant cash advance debt can make a small-business reorganization considerably more complicated. MCA funders often claim rights to receivables, hold UCC liens, and continue to assert substantial balances after a business has fallen behind. The trustee needs to understand those claims to help develop a workable plan. Whether an MCA is a true receivables purchase or a loan can affect the business's options. Still, the debtor's attorney should investigate those issues rather than assume the trustee will litigate them.
This is especially important when several MCA funders are collecting from the same business. Their contracts, liens, payment histories, and claims can affect what the company has available to operate and what creditors are entitled to receive under a plan.
MCA Recharacterization: Loan vs. True Sale of Receivables
Just because an MCA agreement calls the transaction a purchase of future receivables does not mean a court will treat it that way. If the business must repay a fixed amount regardless of revenue, and there is no real way to adjust payments when sales decline, the agreement could be considered a loan. That can matter in bankruptcy because the funder's rights and claims depend in part on how the transaction is classified. What matters is how the agreement actually works, not just what the funder calls it.
Courts look at whether the funder actually assumes the risk that the business brings in less revenue than expected. That means reviewing the repayment terms, reconciliation provisions, default clauses, personal guarantees, and security interests. In CapCall, LLC v. Foster (In re Shoot the Moon, LLC), the court reviewed agreements presented as purchases of receivables and found that the terms supported treating them as loans. The case shows why the actual repayment obligations matter more than the language used to describe the transaction.
UCC Liens, Stacking, and Preference Avoidance
When a business takes on multiple merchant cash advances, the liens can become a problem. MCA funders often file UCC financing statements against business assets, and several funders can end up claiming rights to the same money or property. This is common when a business has stacked advances from different funders. Before putting together a reorganization plan, the business needs to know which liens are valid and which creditors actually have priority. Filing a UCC statement alone does not settle those questions.
The timing of those liens also matters. Some liens granted or perfected within 90 days before bankruptcy can be challenged as preferential transfers, depending on the circumstances and available defenses. If the court avoids a lien, the funder can lose the secured position it was relying on. An attorney should review the filing dates and underlying agreements before accepting a funder's claim to first rights in the business's assets.
Once the business files for bankruptcy, the automatic stay generally stops MCA funders from continuing collection activity, including ACH withdrawals for debts incurred before filing. If a funder keeps taking money after learning about the bankruptcy, it can face consequences for violating the stay. The business should make sure its attorney quickly notifies funders and banks and addresses any continued withdrawals.
Personal Guarantees Survive the Business Bankruptcy
One issue business owners sometimes overlook is that filing the company for bankruptcy usually does not eliminate their personal guarantees. The business can reorganize its MCA debt, but the owner can still be personally responsible for repayment. The automatic stay generally does not protect an owner who has not filed for personal bankruptcy. Unless the court provides separate protection, the funder can continue pursuing the owner even while the business works through its bankruptcy case.
Address that personal exposure before filing. Otherwise, an owner can spend months reorganizing the business only to find MCA funders still pursuing them personally. A proper merchant cash advance restructuring review should look at what the business owes, which liens the funders hold, and what the owners personally guaranteed.
What Should Business Owners Expect When a Subchapter V Trustee Is Appointed?
The trustee becomes involved early in the case. Owners should expect questions about the company's finances, participation in the meeting of creditors, and discussions about how the business plans to pay creditors. At the same time, the business generally continues operating under existing management. The better prepared the company is with its records and a realistic plan, the more productive those discussions tend to be.
The U.S. Trustee arranges the appointment after the case is filed. The debtor must provide accurate financial disclosures, including information about assets, liabilities, income, expenses, and recent transactions. Missing records and inconsistent numbers create avoidable problems. The trustee also attends the meeting of creditors, where the debtor's representative answers questions under oath. It is a routine part of bankruptcy, but it should not be treated casually.
The 90-day plan deadline begins on the filing date, so work on the plan cannot wait until the business has settled every dispute with its MCA funders. Extensions are possible only under the applicable standard. Eligibility also needs to be confirmed before filing, including the current Subchapter V debt ceiling and the nature of the business's debts. Congress has changed the ceiling over time, so an outdated figure is not a safe basis for deciding whether the company qualifies.
The Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts publishes bankruptcy filing data that can help put Subchapter V filings in context. For an individual business, though, the more useful questions are whether it qualifies, whether it can fund a plan, and whether reorganization will leave it in a position to keep operating.
Why Do MCA Cases End Up in New York Courts Regardless of Where the Business Operates?
Many MCA agreements select New York law and require disputes to be heard in New York courts. That can put a business located anywhere in the United States into a New York MCA lawsuit. A forum clause is not the only issue a court considers, and it does not automatically move a bankruptcy case to New York. But a company outside the state should not assume that its location prevents a funder from suing it in New York under an enforceable agreement.
The U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of New York serves Manhattan, the Bronx, and several surrounding counties. The U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Eastern District of New York serves Brooklyn, Queens, Nassau, and Suffolk counties. A business generally files bankruptcy in a district where venue is proper under federal law, which is often where it is based. Disputes involving MCA contracts can raise issues of New York law and forum. Still, an MCA forum clause does not automatically require a Subchapter V case or its related litigation to proceed in a New York bankruptcy court.
Ira Reid brings experience from a federal bankruptcy clerkship in the Eastern District of New York and his work as a restructuring partner at Baker McKenzie. J. Singer Law Group represents businesses across the United States with MCA problems. When the firm represents a business in an MCA lawsuit, that lawsuit must be filed in New York. The business involved in that New York case can be located anywhere in the country.
Common Mistakes to Avoid in a Subchapter V Case
- Treating the trustee as an adversary. The trustee is not there to take over your business. Their job is to help the reorganization move forward. Withholding financial records or giving incomplete answers creates problems and makes it harder for the trustee to work with you. Be ready to explain your finances, answer questions honestly, and work with your attorney when disagreements come up.
- Waiting until the 90-day deadline to analyze MCA claims. Review MCA agreements, payment histories, and UCC filings before filing whenever possible, or as soon as the case begins. If you wait until the reorganization plan is due to question a funder’s lien or whether an MCA agreement is actually a loan, you have less time to investigate your options. Those questions can affect how the entire reorganization is handled.
- Filing Subchapter V without a parallel strategy for personal MCA guarantee exposure. Filing bankruptcy for the company does not automatically eliminate the personal guarantees signed by its owners. The automatic stay also generally does not stop MCA funders from pursuing an owner who has not filed personally. Before filing, you need to know what you still owe and whether you can negotiate or address those guarantees separately.
- Assuming the current debt ceiling from memory. The debt limit for Subchapter V has changed since the law took effect. Relying on an outdated number can send a business down the wrong bankruptcy path and cost it time and money. Confirm the current debt limit and all other eligibility requirements with your attorney before filing.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does a Subchapter V trustee actually do?
The Subchapter V trustee attends the meeting of creditors, works with the business and its creditors to reach an agreement on a reorganization plan, and reports on those efforts. If the court approves a plan without creditor consent, the trustee generally handles payments under that plan. The trustee does not normally take over management or run the company. The business owner usually stays in charge throughout the bankruptcy process.
Does the Subchapter V trustee take over my business?
No. In most Subchapter V cases, you continue running your business, making operating decisions, and working with your attorney on a reorganization plan. The trustee helps with negotiations and handles certain responsibilities during the case, but does not ordinarily manage the company. Every Subchapter V case has a trustee, so the appointment does not mean you have done anything wrong. The court can remove a debtor from possession for cause, but that is not the usual arrangement.
How does a Subchapter V trustee differ from a Chapter 7 trustee?
A Chapter 7 trustee generally takes control of the bankruptcy estate’s assets, sells property when appropriate, and uses the proceeds to pay creditors. A Subchapter V trustee has a different job. The business usually stays open, the owner continues managing it, and the trustee helps work toward a reorganization plan. For an owner trying to keep the company operating, that difference matters.
Can the Subchapter V trustee challenge a merchant cash advance funder’s claim?
Yes, if there are legal grounds and the trustee has authority to bring the challenge. The trustee can challenge an MCA agreement as a disguised loan, and certain UCC liens or transfers made before bankruptcy. But the trustee is not automatically responsible for pursuing every claim against an MCA funder. Your attorney should review the agreements, determine which challenges apply, and identify who can bring them. In re Shoot the Moon, LLC is one example of a court looking at how an MCA transaction actually worked rather than relying on the funder’s description.
What happens to MCA ACH withdrawals when a business files Subchapter V?
Filing Subchapter V generally triggers an automatic stay that stops MCA funders from collecting debts owed before bankruptcy, including via ACH withdrawals. The business should notify its funders and banks right away so it can address scheduled payments. If a funder knowingly continues collecting in violation of the stay, the court can take action. Exceptions exist, and the business still needs to ensure its banking arrangements are handled properly after filing.
My business is outside New York: does New York law still apply to my MCA agreements in a Subchapter V case?
It can. Many MCA agreements contain provisions requiring New York law to apply or disputes to be handled in New York courts. Those terms can matter even if your business operates in Texas, Florida, California, or another state. However, they do not automatically determine where you must file your bankruptcy case or any related dispute. J. Singer Law Group works with businesses throughout the United States on MCA matters and represents businesses in MCA lawsuits filed in New York, regardless of where the business itself is located.
What Business Owners Should Know Before Filing Subchapter V
A Subchapter V trustee is not there to take over your business. The trustee's job is to help move the reorganization forward while you continue running the company. But keeping control of the business doesn't make the process simple. You still need accurate financial records, a realistic repayment plan, and a clear understanding of what your creditors can claim.
That is especially important when merchant cash advances are involved. Review MCA agreements, UCC liens, and personal guarantees before filing. A business that enters Subchapter V without understanding those obligations may face problems that should have been addressed earlier.
J. Singer Law Group works with businesses across the United States on MCA matters and represents businesses in MCA litigation filed in New York, regardless of where the business operates. Our attorneys bring commercial litigation and bankruptcy experience to cases involving MCA debt, creditor disputes, and business restructuring. If your business is considering Subchapter V, call (917) 905-8280 to discuss your options before filing.











